YouTube has a new plan for enforcing its “under 18” restrictions: artificial intelligence will scan your watch history and search history to guess your age. If the AI thinks you’re a minor, your account will be locked into “under 18 mode.” The only way to get back to full access? Submit a government ID, a selfie, or a credit card.
This sounds like a tech dystopia waiting to happen. Let’s break down the problems.
1. AI Guesswork Is Not Proof of Age
AI can analyze your viewing and search patterns, but it can’t actually know your age. Watching Minecraft videos, for example, doesn’t make you a child. Searching for high school sports doesn’t mean you’re a student. And adults can enjoy content marketed toward teens without losing their rights.
Yet YouTube’s system will operate on statistical guesswork, not certainty. That means plenty of adults will be mislabeled — and wrongly forced to hand over private documents just to watch videos freely.
2. Privacy Nightmare
If YouTube gets it wrong, your only way to fix it is to surrender sensitive personal information. That means:
-
Government ID: Handing over your driver’s license to Big Tech, adding one more data point for them to store (and possibly leak).
-
Selfie Verification: Allowing facial recognition technology to link your image to your online viewing habits.
-
Credit Card: Forcing you to share financial details to prove adulthood.
For privacy-minded Americans — especially conservatives who distrust centralized data collection — this is unacceptable. Once this data is in YouTube’s hands, it’s a matter of when, not if, it’s abused, leaked, or cross-linked to other platforms.
3. Discrimination Against the Privacy-Conscious
Plenty of adults — particularly those wary of Big Tech’s surveillance — don’t want to upload government documents to use a video platform. This policy effectively punishes anyone who values anonymity online.
Ironically, the people most likely to resist handing over ID are law-abiding adults — not children. In practice, the system will inconvenience grown-ups far more than it stops actual minors from bypassing restrictions.
4. Mission Creep Is Inevitable
If YouTube can scan your history for age verification today, what stops them from scanning for political beliefs tomorrow? Or “extremist content”? Or anything they decide violates “community standards”? This sets a dangerous precedent where AI-powered profiling controls access to the digital public square.
5. The Workaround Problem
Kids are tech-savvy. If YouTube rolls this out, minors will simply create new accounts, spoof their activity, or use VPNs. The system will catch honest adults far more often than it stops determined teenagers.
Conclusion
YouTube’s AI age verification scheme is a classic example of Big Tech overreach: a flawed system that erodes privacy, mislabels users, and puts sensitive data in the hands of corporations. It will not meaningfully stop minors from accessing restricted content — but it will make ordinary, law-abiding adults jump through invasive hoops just to enjoy a free internet.
The message is clear: if you let Big Tech dictate who you are based on what you watch, your freedoms are only one algorithm update away from disappearing.